Car Seat vs. CARES Harness vs. Travel Vest: Which Is Best for Your Trip?

Car Seat vs. CARES Harness vs. Travel Vest: Which Is Best for Your Trip?

Choosing the right child restraint system for travel involves balancing safety, convenience, and regulatory compliance. Traditional car seats offer the highest crash protection for car travel but can be bulky for planes and rideshares. The FAA-certified CARES harness is lightweight, easy to install on aircraft seats, and approved for children 22–44 lbs up to 40 in tall. Travel vests (e.g., RideSafer) meet FMVSS 213 for ground travel and are low-profile for rideshares, but are not FAA-approved for in-flight use unless the manufacturer obtains specific FAA certification. This guide breaks down age/size guidelines, airline rules, installation differences, and a side-by-side safety comparison to help you pick the best option for your trip.

Overview: Car Seat, CARES Harness, and Travel Vest Explained

The world of child restraints has evolved to include three main travel solutions:

  • Car Seats: Rear- or forward-facing seats that meet FMVSS 213 and AAP recommendations for use in cars and on approved aircraft installations.
  • CARES Harness: FAA-approved Child Aviation Restraint System for children 22–44 lbs and up to 40 in tall, using the aircraft’s existing seat belt for supplemental protection.
  • Travel Vests (RideSafer): FMVSS 213-compliant vests for cars, rideshares, buses, and trains; comfortable and compact but not yet FAA-certified for airplane use.

Age/Size Guidelines (Who Should Use Each)

Ensuring the correct fit is crucial for safety:

  • Car Seats: Infants to booster stage, typically rear-facing until ≥2 years or per seat limits, then forward-facing with harness until 40–65 lbs and 49 inches tall.
  • CARES Harness: Children ≥1 year old, 22–44 lbs, up to 40 in tall, capable of sitting upright unaided.
  • Travel Vests: RideSafer
    – XS: 22–40 lbs, 34–52 inches tall
    – S–L: 30–80 lbs, 34–57 inches tall
    Adjust sizes via velcro & buckle.

Airlines: When to Use a CARES Harness (approved for 22–44 lbs)

According to FAA Advisory Circular AC 120-87C, airlines must allow FAA-certified child aviation restraints like CARES, using the aircraft lap belt for attachment.

Use CARES when: Your child meets the 22–44 lbs & ≤40 in criteria and you want optimal in-flight protection without hauling a bulky car seat.

Limitations: No use for children >44 lbs/40 in without FAA exemption; CARES cannot replace certified car seats for ground vehicles.

Travel Vests (RideSafer) – Pros and Cons

Pros

  • Compact & lightweight; fits in carry-on or diaper bag.
  • FMVSS 213 compliance ensures crash protection for cars/rideshares.
  • Easy to don like a vest, adjustable for growing children.

Cons

  • Not FAA-approved for airplane use; airline acceptance varies.
  • Learning curve to adjust correctly; tightened velcro/buckles require practice.
  • Less body support in severe impacts than full car seats.

Installation Differences (Plane vs Car vs Rideshare)

Car Seat: LATCH or seat belt installation— follow manufacturer manual, ensure tight fit, angle per harness labels.

CARES Harness: Loop around seat headrest, clip to existing lap belt per CARES instructions— no additional tether required.

Travel Vest: Child wears vest; seat belt threaded through belt guides at shoulders and hips— confirm snug fit & no slack.

Safety Comparison: Security vs Convenience

Feature Car Seat CARES Harness Travel Vest
Demo Weight/Height From newborn to ~65 lbs / ~49 in 22–44 lbs / ≤40 in XS 22–40 lbs, S–L 30–80 lbs / 34–57 in
FAA-Approved (Airplane) Yes (when certified for aircraft use) Yes No
FMVSS 213 (Car) Yes No (aircraft only) Yes
Ease of Transport Bulky, heavy Light, folds small Vest-style, flat pack
Installation Skill Moderate (LATCH/belt) Easy (clip & belt) Easy–Moderate (vest adjust)
Cost Range $50–$300+ ≈$80–$100 ≈$100–$150

FAQ

Can I use a travel vest on an airplane?
No—travel vests are not FAA-approved for in-flight use; airlines may refuse.

When is a CARES harness allowed?
On any U.S. airline flight for children 22–44 lbs up to 40 in tall, occupying their own seat.

Do I still need a car seat if I have a travel vest?
Yes—for any car or rideshare, a car seat or FMVSS 213-compliant vest is mandatory by law.

Which is safer: car seat or CARES?
In cars, a dedicated car seat provides superior crash protection; in planes, the FAA endorses CARES over using lap belts alone.

Legal & Liability Disclaimer: This article is for informational purposes only and does not replace professional advice. Always follow manufacturer instructions and airline policies. Consult a certified Child Passenger Safety Technician (CPST) for personalized guidance. Neither the author nor publisher assumes any liability for use of these recommendations.

Authoritative Sources: FAA Advisory Circular AC 120-87C; AmSafe CARES; RideSafer FMVSS 213 compliance.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Best Travel Car Seats for Toddlers and Big Kids (By Age Group)

Image
Best Travel Car Seats for Toddlers and Big Kids (By Age Group) When it comes to traveling with little ones, choosing the right car seat not only ensures safety but also eases your journey. This guide breaks down the top travel car seats by age group, from convertible seats for toddlers to portable boosters for big kids, and covers FAA and car guidelines, performance on trips, and real-world parent testing. Choosing the Right Seat for 1–3 Year Olds (Convertible Seats) Convertible seats allow extended rear-facing use, providing superior protection for toddlers in crashes. Look for models that combine lightweight design with compact folding for travel: WAYB Pico Portable Car Seat • Weight: 3 lb, folds to carry-on size • Fit: 22–50 lb, up to 45 in tall • Features: Airline-approved, quick fold/unfold, durable shell Graco Extend2Fit 3-in-1 • Weight: 12 lb • Fit: Rear-facing to 50 lb, forw...
Read more

Car Seat Laws by State: A US Road Trip Checklist

Image
Car Seat Laws by State: A US Road Trip Checklist | 2025 Expert Guide Car Seat Laws by State: A US Road Trip Checklist • Last updated May 4, 2025 Planning a multi‑state road trip? Each of the 50 states (plus D.C.) enforces its own child car seat regulations , varying by age, weight, and height requirements. Federal guidelines from the American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP) set best‑practice standards, but state laws are legally binding—and fines for noncompliance can reach $500 or more. This checklist will help you compare key rules, avoid penalties, and keep your child as safe as possible on every leg of your journey. Watch: Car Seat Safety Laws State by State Why Laws Vary by State State vs. Federal Guidelines (AAP Recommendations) While the AAP recommends keeping children: • Rear‑facing until at least age 2 (or until they reach the seat’s highest weight/height limit), • Forward‑facing with a 5‑po...
Read more

Cruising and Tours with Kids: Car Seat Policies & Tips

Image
Cruising and Tours with Kids: Car Seat Policies & Tips | 2025 Expert Guide Cruising and Tours with Kids: Car Seat Policies & Tips Written by the blog team • Last updated May 5, 2025 Family cruises and guided tours offer unforgettable memories—but keeping your child safe means knowing each mode’s car seat rules. From storing seats in your cabin to shore‑excursion transfers on buses without seat belts, this guide covers everything you need for worry‑free travel on sea and land. Watch: Tips for Cruising Carnival with a Toddler Bringing Car Seats on Cruise Ships Storage and Cabin Use (e.g. cribs vs. seats) Most major cruise lines—including Carnival—allow you to bring your own car seat onboard and store it in your stateroom. According to Carnival’s “Traveling with Infants and Toddlers” policy, “Car seats may be brought on board and stored in your stateroom” :contentReference[oaicite:1]{index=1}. Keep harness...
Read more